Seared Venison Backstrap

Tender and juicy Seared Venison Backstrap is a perfectly elegant and delicious dish that's easy to cook.

Finish this delicious venison with a drizzle of seasoned garlic butter sauce or a port wine sauce.

Cooking venison

Wild game, including venison or elk, can be absolutely delicious. However, some cuts, like this venison backstrap needs to be cooked carefully to avoid the meat from becoming too tough and dry.

Searing backstrap isn't difficult, and when you cook it perfectly, the meat is so juicy and delicious. Use a hot cast iron skillet for the best results.

My recommendation is to cook the meat to medium rare. If that's too rare for you, then shoot for medium. Any more than medium will result in a very dry piece of meat.

Backstrap vs. tenderloin

Many people often confuse backstrap and tenderloin. Some of the confusion comes from the shape of the meat but also backstrap is also referred to as a loin or loin roast. The loin and tenderloin are two different cuts.

Backstrap is a tender cut of meat that is located along the long side of the top of the spine of the deer.

Tenderloins are located behind the ribs in the abdominal area. The tenderloins are much smaller in size. This is considered the filet mignon that you'd find in beef. It's a premium cut of meat.

The tenderloins are much smaller in size than the backstrap. In comparison, the backstrap weighed 16 ounces and the tenderloins were about 7 ounces each. This will vary depending on the size of your deer.

You can see they are very different in size. Both cuts are equally as tender. This recipe uses the backstrap. You can also use the tenderloin if you'd prefer, but because of the small size, the cooking time will be quick.

If using the tenderloin, just do a quick sear on each side and then remove and allow the meat to rest for about 10 minutes. Don't finish the tenderloin in the oven like we do with the backstrap.

• Venison Backstrap - You could also use another wild game backstrap like elk backstrap. The cuts will typically be larger than venison, so your cooking times will increase. My backstrap was about 1 pound. Weight will vary depending on the size of your deer.
  • Remove as much of the silverskin as possible from your backstrap
• Salt - I like to use coarse salt in this recipe. Use kosher or flaked sea salt. You could also use a salt blend, like this rosemary salt.
• Seasoning - Ground pepper, garlic powder, and fresh rosemary. I prefer to keep it simple. Feel free to swap out the rosemary for thyme.
• Butter sauce - The butter sauce is optional but adds a delicious finish to the meat. I use salted butter, minced fresh garlic, fresh rosemary, and fresh parsley. Fresh thyme and black pepper can also be added.

Step by step directions

• Pat your backstrap dry with a paper towel
• Rub a very light amount of oil across the surface of the meat
• Sprinkle with salt and seasonings. Be certain to season all sides.
• Heat a cast iron or heavy ovenproof skillet over medium-high heat. Add 1-2 tablespoons of oil.
• Add the backstrap and brown each side. You are trying to achieve a nice sear which will help lock in the moisture.

• Place skillet in a hot oven for 5-10 minutes until the internal temperature reaches 130°F. Use an instant-read thermometer to determine the temperature.
• Remove the pan and place the backstrap on a plate. Loosely cover with foil and let rest for 10-15 minutes then slice and serve.
• To make the garlic butter sauce, use the same pan as the meat was cooked in. Allow the pan to cool for a few minutes.
• Add butter, garlic, and parsley. Swirl ingredients together over low heat until everything is melted and the garlic is fragrant.
• Remove from heat and pour over backstrap or serve in a small dish

Recipe tips

• Don't overcook or the venison will become very dry and tough
• Be certain to obtain a good sear on all sides. Cook on each side just once, until nicely browned.
• Once in the oven, the temperature will rise quickly. Start cooking for .... minutes and then check your temperature. If needed, put it back in the oven for a few minutes longer.
• The temperature will continue to rise slightly while the meat is resting out of the oven
• Allow the meat to rest for 10-15 minutes. This will allow the juices to stay in the meat and won't run all over the cutting board.
• Serve with garlic butter sauce or homemade wine sauce

Frequently asked questions

More delicious venison recipes

• Chili with beans
• Venison jerky
• Venison stew
• Homemade venison pastrami

More from Beyond The Chicken Coop

If you make this recipe, I’d love to hear about it! Leave a comment below and snap a picture and tag me on Instagram @beyondthechickencoop

Check out all my delicious wild game recipes!